There comes a point when many longtime homeowners look around the house they love and ask themselves a question they never expected to have to answer:

“Should I stay here, or is it time to move?”

Maybe you’ve lived in your Chicago home for 20, 30, or even 40 years. You raised your family there. You know the neighbors. You know which floorboard creaks, where the best sunlight comes through in the morning, and exactly how the neighborhood has changed over the years.

Your home isn’t just real estate.

It’s part of your story.

That’s why deciding whether to age in place or sell and move to something that better fits your current lifestyle can feel overwhelming.

The good news is that there isn’t one right answer.

The goal isn’t to convince yourself to move—or convince yourself to stay. The goal is to look at your home, your finances, your health, your lifestyle, and the future you want and determine which option gives you the greatest combination of comfort, independence, safety, and peace of mind.

Here are seven questions that can help.

1. Does Your Home Still Fit the Way You Live Today?

Think about the house you originally purchased versus the life you have now.

Maybe you needed four bedrooms when your children were at home. Today, two of those rooms may rarely be used.

Maybe you once loved having a large yard. Now mowing the lawn, clearing leaves, maintaining landscaping, or shoveling Chicago snow feels more like work than enjoyment.

Ask yourself:

• How much of my home do I actually use?
• Am I maintaining rooms I rarely enter?
• Is taking care of the property becoming stressful?
• Would I prefer something smaller and easier to maintain?
• Does my home still add to my quality of life?

Having extra space isn’t automatically a reason to sell.

But if maintaining that space is costing you significant time, money, or energy, it may be worth considering your alternatives.

2. Could You Live Safely and Comfortably in the Home 5 or 10 Years From Now?

One of the most important parts of aging in place is looking ahead—not just at what works today.

Many Chicago homes, especially older bungalows, two-flats, greystones, and multi-level homes, weren’t necessarily designed with aging in place in mind.

Consider things such as:

Stairs: Do you have to climb stairs to reach your bedroom, bathroom, laundry room, or front entrance?

Bathrooms: Is there room to safely maneuver? Could grab bars, a walk-in shower, or other modifications be added?

Entrances: Are there steep steps leading into the home?

Laundry: Is your washer and dryer located in the basement?

Lighting: Are hallways, staircases, and entrances well lit?

Maintenance: Could you realistically continue handling repairs and upkeep, or would you need outside help?

Sometimes relatively simple modifications can make staying in the home comfortable for many more years.

Other times, the amount of renovation required makes moving into a home with fewer stairs, single-level living, an elevator, or accessible features more practical.

3. What Is It Really Costing You to Stay?

If your mortgage is paid off, it can be tempting to think, “Why would I ever move? My house is already paid for.”

That’s an important advantage—but a mortgage isn’t the only cost of homeownership.

Consider your total annual expenses:

• Property taxes
• Homeowners insurance
• Utilities
• Repairs
• Lawn care
• Snow removal
• Roof, plumbing, electrical, and HVAC maintenance
• Exterior maintenance
• Security
• Cleaning
• Unexpected repairs

A large older home may cost significantly more to operate than a smaller condo, townhome, ranch-style home, apartment, or senior living community.

On the other hand, moving also has costs.

That’s why I encourage homeowners to look at both sides of the equation before making a decision.

For Cook County homeowners, it is also worth reviewing whether you’re receiving every property-tax exemption for which you may qualify, including exemptions available to eligible senior homeowners.

4. What Would Selling Allow You to Do?

Sometimes homeowners focus so much on what they would be leaving that they haven’t thought about what they could be gaining.

Selling doesn’t necessarily mean giving something up.

It may mean creating a lifestyle that works better for your next chapter.

Imagine:

No more shoveling snow.

No more worrying about replacing an aging roof.

Less house to clean.

Lower maintenance responsibilities.

Living closer to your children or grandchildren.

Traveling without worrying as much about who’s watching the house.

Moving to a building with an elevator.

Living somewhere you can walk to restaurants, shopping, parks, transportation, or medical appointments.

Or simply having a home that feels easier.

For some homeowners, selling a longtime property can also unlock equity that may be useful for retirement, purchasing a smaller home, traveling, helping family, or creating additional financial flexibility.

That doesn’t automatically mean selling is the best choice.

It simply means your home is both an emotional asset and a financial asset, and it’s worth understanding what options that asset gives you.

5. Is Your Community Still Meeting Your Needs?

Sometimes the home itself works perfectly—but the location no longer does.

Think about your everyday life.

Can you easily get to:

• Grocery stores?
• Medical appointments?
• Family and friends?
• Restaurants?
• Parks?
• Public transportation?
• Community activities?
• Places of worship?
• Shopping and other services?

Chicago can be a wonderful place to age because many neighborhoods offer established communities, public transportation, walkability, parks, healthcare options, and familiar local businesses.

But your needs at 70 may be different from your needs at 40.

The question isn’t simply, “Do I still like my neighborhood?”

It’s:

“Will this neighborhood support the lifestyle I want over the next decade?”

6. Are You Staying Because You Want To—or Because Moving Feels Overwhelming?

This may be the most important question in this entire article.

Sometimes homeowners truly want to remain in their homes.

And if staying is safe, financially manageable, and consistent with the life they want, aging in place may be an excellent choice.

But sometimes the real answer is:

“I’d probably move if I didn’t have to deal with all this stuff.”

After decades in a home, the thought of sorting through closets, furniture, photographs, paperwork, dishes, clothing, keepsakes, and everything accumulated over the years can make moving seem impossible.

That’s understandable.

But downsizing doesn’t have to happen in one weekend.

It can be done gradually and with a plan.

Start with one drawer.

Then one closet.

Then one room.

Decide what you want to:

Keep. Give to family. Sell. Donate. Recycle. Discard.

You don’t have to erase your memories to move forward.

Your memories are yours.

They aren’t measured by the number of things you keep.

7. If You Did Move, Where Would You Go?

Before putting a For Sale sign in the yard, you should know what comes next.

That’s especially important for older homeowners.

Your next move might be:

• A smaller single-family home
• A ranch-style home
• A condominium
• A townhome
• A 55+ community
• An apartment
• An independent living community
• A home closer to family
• Another Chicago neighborhood
• A Chicago suburb
• Another state entirely

You don’t necessarily have to know the exact address yet.

But you should have an idea of what you want your next chapter to feel like.

Do you want less maintenance?

More community?

More walkability?

A quieter environment?

One-level living?

More opportunities to travel?

Closer proximity to family?

Start with the lifestyle.

Here’s a simple way to think about it.

Then find the housing that supports it.

So…Should You Stay or Sell?

Aging in place may make sense if:

Your home is affordable, manageable, safe or reasonably adaptable, you have access to the services and support you need, and most importantly—you genuinely want to stay.

Downsizing or moving may make sense if:

Maintaining the home has become physically or financially burdensome, accessibility is becoming an issue, you’re using only a small portion of the house, you’d like to unlock some of your equity, or another housing option would better support the lifestyle you want.

And remember:

Deciding to explore selling your home is not the same as deciding to sell your home.

You are allowed to gather information first.

In fact, that’s exactly what I recommend.

Start With Information, Not a For Sale Sign

One of the biggest misconceptions about talking to a Realtor® is that the conversation has to end with your home going on the market.

It doesn’t.

As a Seniors Real Estate Specialist® (SRES®) serving Chicago and the surrounding suburbs, my role is to help older adults and their families understand their real estate options so they can make informed decisions without feeling rushed or pressured.

Before deciding anything, we can talk about:

• What your home may be worth
• How much equity you may have
• What selling expenses could look like
• What updates may—or may not—be necessary before selling
• Downsizing strategies
• Housing possibilities for your next move
• The timing of selling and purchasing
• How to make the transition more manageable
• Questions you should be asking before making a decision

And sometimes, after looking at everything, the best decision may be to stay exactly where you are.

That’s okay, too.

My job isn’t to convince you to move.

My job is to help you understand your options.

Your Next Chapter Should Feel Like Yours

A home can hold decades of birthdays, holidays, family dinners, laughter, losses, celebrations, and everyday moments.

Leaving it can be emotional.

But so can imagining the possibilities ahead.

Whether you ultimately choose to stay, renovate, downsize, relocate, or simply start planning, you deserve the time and information necessary to make a decision that feels right for you.

You don’t have to figure everything out today.

You just need to know your options.

---

Thinking About Downsizing—but Not Sure Where to Begin?

Download my FREE “Downsizing Without the Stress” Guide for practical tips to help you start organizing, planning, and thinking through your next move.

And if you’re wondering what your Chicago-area home is worth or simply want to talk through whether staying or selling makes sense, I’d be happy to have a no-pressure conversation with you.

Bettina Yarbrough, SRES®
Chicago Realtor® | Serving Chicago & Surrounding Suburbs
BettinaTheRealtor.com

Your next chapter deserves a plan—and you don’t have to make it alone.